Options

In Short

This collection of short stories explores the whimsical and often ironic nature of human decision-making. Set against the backdrop of an expanding American frontier and the bustling, anonymous streets of New York, the tales focus on individuals—from Southern colonels and struggling shop-girls to eccentric hermits—who find themselves at critical crossroads. Through sharp dialogue and unexpected narrative twists, the collection highlights how the small "options" people choose define their characters. Its enduring appeal lies in its empathy for the underdog and its masterful, often humorous, observation of human behavior.

The Story

The narrative arc of the collection mirrors the unpredictability of its characters' lives. We begin in the South, where Colonel Aquila Telfair, a man defined by tradition and a library of obsolete books, attempts to preserve his legacy by editing a regional magazine. His world is soon disrupted by the intrusion of Northern practicality and the changing tides of history, forcing him to engage with a reality he once viewed as hostile. From the stagnant, history-laden halls of Southern manors, the stories shift to the "Vallambrosa" apartment houses of New York, where shop-girls and starving artists navigate the harsh realities of poverty, hunger, and unexpected romance.

In these urban settings, the drama is intimate and immediate. A hungry girl and a desperate stranger might find their fates linked by a simple onion, or a young woman might brave a blizzard to keep a midnight appointment with an artist, only to find that the most daring "option" is to reject social convention and marry on the spot. The stories move fluidly between these personal stakes and larger, more absurd ones, such as a man who hides a fugitive to pay his own debts, or a group of men who engage in a war of wits—and lies—over the affections of a local girl in a "mushroom" town.

Throughout the collection, the themes of artifice and authenticity collide. We see characters like the "hermit," who has spent ten years in a mountain cave to nurse a broken heart, suddenly abandon his philosophy when a waltz plays in the distance, proving that even the most stubborn resolve can be undone by a memory. Similarly, in military settings, the pursuit of glory is revealed to be less about heroism and more about the mundane necessity of money or the desire for fame.

The stories do not offer grand moral resolutions. Instead, they end on notes of quiet, often humorous, resignation. Whether it is a man finding himself unexpectedly married to the sister of the woman he thought he loved, or a group of suitors realizing they have all been outmaneuvered by a woman’s own ambition to study music in Boston, the endings are rarely what the characters anticipated. The collection concludes that life is a matter of managing one’s own illusions, and that the "options" we present to the world are often just masks for the simpler, deeper human hungers that drive us all.

How It Unfolds

The Southern remnant Colonel Telfair attempts to uphold the dignity of a fading culture through his editorial work, only to find himself forced to print the words of a modern Northern politician. His struggle represents the collision between a romanticized past and an encroaching, pragmatic future.

The urban struggle In the crowded tenements of New York, characters navigate hunger and social friction with a mixture of grit and humor. A stray onion becomes the centerpiece of a social invitation, highlighting how desperation often dictates the terms of human connection.

The mask of the hermit A man who has renounced civilization for a decade finds his resolve crumbling at the sound of a waltz. He is forced to confront the absurdity of his self-imposed exile and the realization that his sacrifice was perhaps a folly.

The game of courtship Suitors in a frontier town compete for the attention of Ileen Hinkle, utilizing flattery and false promises. Their rivalry is eventually rendered moot when Ileen chooses her own path, demonstrating that women are often far more capable of agency than their suitors assume.

The ironic conclusion The stories frequently resolve with characters realizing that their carefully constructed narratives have been subverted by chance. Whether through a mistaken marriage or a failed business venture, the protagonists learn that life rarely adheres to their rigid plans.

The People

Colonel Aquila Telfair serves as the archetypal figure of the Old South, clinging to his library and his pride. He seeks to maintain a veneer of classicism in a world that has moved on, yet he remains surprisingly flexible when confronted with the reality of his own financial decline.

Hetty, a resilient shop-girl, represents the pragmatic, often sharp-tongued spirit of the city. She wants only a decent meal and a bit of human connection, and she uses her wits to navigate the indifference of the urban environment.

The "hermit" is a man defined by his ten-year effort to live in defiance of a past heartbreak. He wants to remain a martyr to his own memory, but he is fundamentally a man of action who discovers that his "renunciatory" life is merely a long, elaborate pose.

Ileen Hinkle, the object of desire in her frontier town, is a character who refuses to be defined by the men who seek her hand. She wants a life of her own making, and she uses the very flattery directed at her to secure her departure for a conservatory, leaving her suitors behind to ponder their own gullibility.

In Its Own Voice

The colonel, embodying a world of fading gentility, speaks with a formal, almost desperate gravity:

"He arose and shook hands punctiliously with each member of the committee."

The struggle for basic survival in the city is captured with a stark, blunt humor:

"I imagine he's been a gentleman, he's so low down now."

The irony of human ambition is perfectly summarized in the observation:

"We discussed things while dogs barked at the moon that rose, as big as a five-cent piece or a flour barrel."

What It's Really About

At its heart, this book is an inquiry into the nature of the "mask." The characters are constantly curating their identities—as heroes, as victims, as scholars, or as lovers—only to have those identities stripped away by the sheer force of circumstance. It argues that there is no such thing as a "mystery" regarding human behavior; rather, people are predictable in their desire to be seen in a certain light. The collection questions the value of the stories we tell ourselves to survive, suggesting that while these illusions provide comfort, they are ultimately fragile, and the most honest path is often the one that embraces the messy, unscripted reality of human need.

Why Read It Today

This book is a delight for those who enjoy the "twist" ending, though it possesses a much deeper melancholy than the term suggests. Reading it feels like walking through a bustling city square in the early 20th century: you hear the sharp, quick-fire slang of the street-corner hustler mixed with the stilted, flowery prose of a dying era. The author has an uncanny ability to find the profound in the trivial, making the reader feel like a witness to the secret lives of strangers.

Modern readers should be prepared for the period-specific attitudes that permeate the stories. The author’s depictions of race, regional identity, and gender dynamics reflect the social conventions of the early 1900s, which can be jarring and, at times, regressive. The prose itself is a stylistic time capsule; it is ornate, playful, and occasionally dense with references to literature and history that may require a second glance. However, if you are willing to navigate these historical artifacts, you will find a collection that rewards you with its warmth. It leaves you with a lingering sense of the absurdity of our own self-importance and a renewed appreciation for the tiny, often overlooked "options" that shape the arc of a life.