myebooksbuy
My Books
Cover of Or Darwin, if you prefer

Free summary

Or Darwin, if you prefer

Mel Hunter (1927–2004)

Science-Fiction & Fantasy6 min read·1,242 words

A lonely man discovers a disembodied mouth and eyes living on his wall, leading to a desperate scheme to swap lives across centuries. Their plan for salvation ends in a fragmented existence trapped between seconds.

In Short

This story follows Henry Harbinger, a man stifled by the crushing, sterile monotony of his 1954 life. He encounters a displaced, weary man named Jones from the year 2094 who communicates through a tear in the fabric of time. Bonded by their mutual, soul-crushing boredom, the two plot to trade places—Harbinger seeking adventure in the future, and Jones seeking escape from a stagnant, over-regulated world. The narrative explores the fragility of existence and the human impulse to trade a known misery for an unknown hope, resulting in a haunting, bittersweet conclusion.

The Story

Mr. Harbinger begins his story by committing a minor act of rebellion: he quits his soul-numbing job at a chemical company, hurling an insult at his supervisor. Returning to his drab, impeccably ordered apartment, he finds his reality fracturing. A mouth and two wandering eyes materialize on his wallpaper. Initially terrified, Harbinger soon realizes that this apparition is not a hallucination, but a man named Jones, a technician from 2094.

Jones reveals that his own time is a stagnant, suffocating place where innovation is forbidden and everything is stored away in "indestructible cocoons" to prevent wear. Despite their disparate centuries, the two men share a profound, bone-deep exhaustion with their lives. They begin to hold clandestine meetings across time, sharing tea and stories, eventually forming a desperate plan to swap identities. Jones promises to forge credentials to slot Harbinger into a high-level research position in the future, while Harbinger offers his own mundane, clean record for Jones to inhabit in 1954.

The plan is simple, or so it seems. Jones prepares the "Time Mechanism" to bridge their lives. However, the future’s power grid is managed by inept, careless technicians. At the precise moment of the transfer, a bored worker at the power plant accidentally shifts his feet, tripping a switch that steals the final, necessary jolt of energy from the mechanism.

The result is a catastrophic failure. Instead of a successful migration, both men are ripped from their respective realities and cast into the chaotic, shifting anomalies of "Variable Time." They lose their physical coherence, becoming fleeting, spectral glimpses of themselves—a lone eye under a leaf, a mouth clinging to a church steeple. The narrative concludes with the narrator reflecting on these sightings. They are no longer men, but echoes, wandering the edges of our reality, forever trapped in the cracks of time, unable to complete their leap or return to the safety of their original lives. The final ambiguity—whether the drifting fragments belong to Harbinger, Darwin, or Jones—underscores the tragedy of their lost humanity.

How It Unfolds

The resignation Harbinger reaches a breaking point at the Cushman Chemical Co., punctuating years of subservience with a sudden, sharp outburst of defiance. He returns home to his suffocatingly neat room, ready to succumb to a lifetime of gray, silent misery.

The anomaly A pair of eyes and a mouth appear on the wallpaper, marking the arrival of Jones, a visitor from 2094. After an initial shock, Harbinger realizes that this bizarre manifestation shares his own profound sense of isolation and dissatisfaction.

The plan The two men bond over cups of tea, discussing their respective eras with a sense of shared exhaustion. They resolve to swap lives, with Jones providing the technological means to bypass the 20th century’s limitations and Harbinger offering his clean identity to provide Jones an escape.

The betrayal of circumstance On the day of the transfer, the technical stability of the future proves an illusion. A careless technician at a power station inadvertently drains the energy required for the migration, sealing the men’s fates.

The eternal drift The transfer fails, leaving both men shattered into fragmented, spectral pieces. They spend their remaining existence as ephemeral, ghostly glitches in our world, occasionally glimpsed as eyes or mouths in improbable, lonely places.

The People

Henry Harbinger is a man defined by his "huge, calibrated double-titrated BOREDOM." He is a creature of habit, living in a room where he has studied the same wallpaper spot for thirteen years. His desire for a life with "zip and a dash" makes him susceptible to the impossible, driving him to trust a disembodied voice in exchange for a chance at a different fate.

Jones is a technician from the future who serves as a dark reflection of Harbinger. He is apathetic, weary, and disillusioned by a society that prioritizes maintenance over progress. He wants to escape a world where perfection is a cage, yet he is ultimately undone by the very incompetence of the bureaucracy he serves.

Together, they represent two sides of the same coin: the victim of the past’s monotony and the victim of the future’s stagnation. Their friendship is a brief, tender connection in a cold universe. By the end, they are stripped of their individual agency, becoming indistinguishable entities—often referred to as "Darwin" by choice—wandering the fringes of reality together as remnants of a dream that could not survive the mechanics of the universe.

In Its Own Voice

"I'm choked by the tedium, the huge, calibrated double-titrated BOREDOM of it all!"

Harbinger confesses his true, inner desperation to the mouth appearing on his wall.

"I had hoped to find a Time when people were lively; when there was zip and a dash to just getting up in the morning; when somebody would care what you did every day."

Jones explains his motivation for reaching back through the centuries to find a more meaningful existence.

What It's Really About

The story serves as a meditation on the crushing weight of institutionalized mediocrity. Both Harbinger and Jones are trapped by their environments—one by the drabness of post-war industrial life, the other by the stifling rigidity of a high-tech future. The "Time Mechanism" is not merely a piece of science fiction hardware; it is a symbol of the human longing to escape the consequences of one's own era. The book argues that the desire for "romance"—the spark of life and individuality—is a universal, persistent struggle. Ultimately, it suggests that when individuals attempt to bypass the structures of their reality to find a better life, they risk losing their own substance to the indifference of the world around them.

Why Read It Today

This story is a sharp, atmospheric gem that will resonate with anyone who has felt alienated by the routine of modern life. It captures the specific, quiet agony of feeling "choked by the tedium" with a grace that elevates its science fiction premise into something far more personal and poignant. You will find it to be a swift, intelligent read that values character psychology over complex scientific jargon. The language is sophisticated and occasionally dry, reflecting the protagonist’s own constrained, "neat and orderly" nature, which contrasts beautifully with the chaotic, surreal imagery of the time-travel mishap.

Readers should be prepared for the mid-century tone, which is deeply rooted in the era’s concerns about conformity and the creeping influence of "Master Power" and bureaucratic control. Some may find the abrupt, spectral ending unsettling or ambiguous, but that is precisely the point; the story leaves you with the haunting image of two souls lost in the cracks of time. It is a work for those who appreciate stories that linger in the mind, asking not just about the mechanics of time travel, but about the cost of searching for a version of oneself that feels more authentic. It remains a timeless, melancholic reminder of the fragility of the human spirit.

This summary was written by AI (gemini-3.1-flash-lite) on 2026-09-21 and is a guide to the book, not a replacement for it — it can be incomplete or wrong. The book itself is public domain. Copyright & AI disclosure · Report a problem

More science-fiction & fantasy

Keep reading

Cover of The white rain came

The white rain came

Merwin, Sam, Jr.

When an inscrutable, planet-spanning intelligence begins killing human colonists, two telepathic spouses must risk their minds and bodies to master a force beyond human comprehension.

Science-Fiction & Fantasy7 min read
Cover of The winner and new

The winner and new

Ib Melchior

In a future where television is the absolute arbiter of reality, two men enter a shimmering force-field to duel for the highest stakes imaginable. Only one will emerge alive, while the other faces a terrifying erasure.

Science-Fiction & Fantasy8 min read
Cover of The vidiot

The vidiot

Ib Melchior

The future is never as safe as we imagine, especially when the barrier between reality and the lens begins to dissolve. A single moment of technical failure can reveal a terrifying, limitless horizon.

Science-Fiction & Fantasy6 min read
Cover of The day the world ended

The day the world ended

Sax Rohmer

A mysterious voice delivers a chilling three-day ultimatum in a quiet German resort town. To stop a mad visionary from extinguishing human life, three investigators must breach a fortress guarded by synthetic giants.

Science-Fiction & Fantasy7 min read
Cover of The Singing Mouse Stories

The Singing Mouse Stories

Emerson Hough

A solitary man sits in a quiet room with a small fire, a worn hunting coat, and a tiny mouse that sings him into visions of lost youth, wild mountains, and the forgotten beauty of the world.

Science-Fiction & Fantasy6 min read
Cover of Tales of Fantasy and Fact

Tales of Fantasy and Fact

Brander Matthews

This collection of short narratives explores the thin, permeable border between the mundane world of Gilded Age New York and the realm of the impossible. These stories challenge our perceptions of reality, suggesting that the fantastic may be hiding in plain sight behind a modern veneer.

Science-Fiction & Fantasy6 min read