The Plot That Failed

In Short

The Plot That Failed is a gripping detective story featuring Nick Carter, a renowned investigator known for his sharp intellect and unwavering determination. The plot revolves around the abduction of Hilton Field, a wealthy banker, and the subsequent murder of his associate, Wilbur Field. As Nick Carter delves into the case, he uncovers a complex web of deceit involving a gang of criminals, a treacherous accomplice, and a mysterious woman. The story is a thrilling blend of mystery, suspense, and clever detective work, showcasing Carter's ability to solve even the most intricate crimes.

The Story

The story begins with the abduction of Hilton Field, a prominent banker, from his home. The crime is orchestrated by a gang of criminals led by Elmer Greer, a cunning and ruthless mastermind. Greer's plan involves not only the abduction but also the murder of Wilbur Field, Hilton's associate, to cover their tracks. The gang's activities are facilitated by a network of accomplices, including a barmaid named Dell Ladley and a mysterious woman named Louise Calhoun.

Nick Carter, the celebrated detective, is called in to investigate the case. His inquiry leads him to a seedy bar where he encounters Dell Ladley, who is secretly working to warn the gang of his presence. Despite her efforts, Carter manages to apprehend Skip Brodie, one of the gang members, and begins to unravel the conspiracy.

As Carter digs deeper, he discovers that Greer has been manipulating events from behind the scenes, using his associates to carry out his plans. The detective's investigation takes him to various locations, including a Pine Street building where he confronts Tom Smith, a broker involved in the scheme. Carter's persistence and cleverness allow him to gather crucial evidence and outwit the criminals at every turn.

The plot thickens when Carter learns that Greer has been using a disguised accomplice, later revealed to be Demas Lorton, to carry out his orders. Lorton, posing as a negro, has been holding Hilton Field captive in a remote cabin. Carter, with the help of his assistant Tambourine Jack, tracks down the cabin and rescues Field, leading to the arrest of Lorton and the breakdown of the gang's operations.

The story culminates in a dramatic confrontation where Carter exposes the entire conspiracy, bringing the criminals to justice. The detective's skill, intuition, and unwavering commitment to truth ensure that the plot that failed is fully unraveled, and justice is served.

How It Unfolds

The Abduction: Hilton Field is abducted from his home by a gang of criminals led by Elmer Greer. The crime is meticulously planned, involving the murder of Wilbur Field to eliminate loose ends.

Nick Carter's Investigation: The renowned detective is called in to solve the case. He begins his inquiry at a seedy bar, where he encounters Dell Ladley, a barmaid secretly working for the gang.

Apprehending Skip Brodie: Despite Dell's attempts to warn the gang, Carter manages to apprehend Skip Brodie, one of the gang members, and starts to piece together the conspiracy.

Uncovering the Mastermind: Carter discovers that Elmer Greer is the mastermind behind the abduction and murder. Greer has been manipulating events from behind the scenes, using his associates to carry out his plans.

Confronting Tom Smith: The detective's investigation leads him to a Pine Street building, where he confronts Tom Smith, a broker involved in the scheme. Carter gathers crucial evidence and outwits Smith.

Rescuing Hilton Field: Carter learns that Greer has been using a disguised accomplice, Demas Lorton, to hold Hilton Field captive. With the help of Tambourine Jack, Carter tracks down the cabin and rescues Field.

Exposing the Conspiracy: The story culminates in a dramatic confrontation where Carter exposes the entire conspiracy, leading to the arrest of the criminals and the resolution of the case.

The People

Nick Carter: The protagonist and master detective, known for his sharp intellect, intuition, and unwavering commitment to justice. He is the driving force behind the investigation, using his skills to unravel the complex plot.

Elmer Greer: The primary antagonist and mastermind behind the abduction and murder. Greer is a cunning and ruthless criminal who manipulates his associates to carry out his plans.

Hilton Field: The wealthy banker who is abducted by the gang. His rescue is a central goal of the story, and his survival is crucial to exposing the conspiracy.

Wilbur Field: Hilton's associate, who is murdered to cover the gang's tracks. His death adds a layer of complexity to the case and motivates Carter's investigation.

Dell Ladley: A barmaid and secret accomplice of the gang. She attempts to warn the criminals of Carter's presence but ultimately fails, leading to her arrest.

Demas Lorton: A disguised accomplice of Greer, posing as a negro to hold Hilton Field captive. His capture is a key moment in the story, as it leads to Field's rescue.

Tambourine Jack: Nick Carter's assistant, who plays a crucial role in tracking down the cabin where Hilton Field is held captive. His loyalty and resourcefulness are essential to the investigation.

In Its Own Voice

"I’m Tambourine Jack," he said, at length, drawing a tambourine from under his coat and jingling it, at which the dog Crackers set up a dismal howl.

This quote introduces Tambourine Jack, a colorful character who assists Nick Carter in his investigation, adding a touch of humor and uniqueness to the story.

"Prepare for the worst, Louise. I fear we stand on the brink of a volcano!"

Elmer Greer's ominous warning to Louise Calhoun highlights the tension and danger surrounding their criminal activities, foreshadowing the impending collapse of their plot.

"You are my prisoner," said the detective, drawing a pair of handcuffs from his pocket.

Nick Carter's decisive action in apprehending Skip Brodie demonstrates his skill and determination, setting the stage for the unraveling of the conspiracy.

What It's Really About

The Plot That Failed is a classic detective story that explores themes of justice, deception, and the triumph of good over evil. The narrative delves into the complexities of criminal conspiracies, highlighting the intricate web of lies and manipulation that criminals use to achieve their goals. It also examines the role of the detective as a figure of justice, someone who uses intellect and intuition to uncover the truth and bring wrongdoers to justice.

The story raises questions about the nature of evil and the lengths to which people will go to achieve their desires. It portrays criminals as cunning and resourceful but ultimately no match for the relentless pursuit of justice. The plot also underscores the importance of loyalty and trust, as seen in the relationship between Nick Carter and his assistant, Tambourine Jack.

Why Read It Today

The Plot That Failed is a thrilling and engaging read for fans of detective stories and mystery novels. Its fast-paced plot, clever twists, and well-drawn characters make it a compelling page-turner. The story's focus on justice and the triumph of good over evil continues to resonate with readers, offering a satisfying resolution to a complex and intriguing mystery.

Readers who enjoy classic detective fiction will appreciate the meticulous detail and logical reasoning that Nick Carter employs to solve the case. The story's portrayal of early 20th-century criminal underworlds adds historical context, making it a fascinating glimpse into the past.

While the language and attitudes reflect the period in which it was written, the story's core themes and suspenseful narrative remain timeless. The book is a quick read, making it ideal for those looking for a short but satisfying literary escape.

The Plot That Failed is a must-read for fans of detective stories, offering a blend of suspense, intrigue, and clever detective work that will keep readers engaged from start to finish. Its enduring appeal lies in its ability to captivate and entertain, leaving readers with a deeper appreciation for the art of detective fiction.